Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-86.46.22.35-20130403153709/@comment-64.33.250.214-20141116001153

0nighthawk0 wrote:

Mgsnerdswe wrote:

You can search in youtube, a lot of evidence, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aSQZyuf5C7E Personally I find myself agreeing a lot with this video, more so because of the fact that a lot of things stated in this video, I have already pointed out loooong ago in the beginnings of this thread.

In response to the poster above me, I've never seen Fight Club, and didn't knew of it's plot twists until it was pointed out in a video I saw about the halucination theory. Please note, I said "people FAMILIAR with Fight Club", not people who've seen it. This theory was founded and supported largely by people with basic knowledge of Fight Club. It's been brought up in videos and these message boards. Popularity often influences perception, and Fight Club is insanely popular.

Regardless, the video you watched is full of holes. For example, Ishmael and Ahab aren't the same person in the book Moby Dick. I would point out the other faults in logic, but quite frankly there's no reward in doing so. People will continue believing these theories until the game is released. I just find a lot of this theory hinges on Ishmael having the same voice actor as Big Boss. Ishmael could just as easily be Decoy Octopus, Solidus, or just a lazy rehiring of the same voice actor (which has happened before in the franchise). It's not like the voices are 100% identical.