Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5085906-20130627191357/@comment-1672596-20150823122633

0nighthawk0 wrote: I am not so much doubting that the guide is real, more so certain information in it. When a guide brings in their own speculation and theories into the mix, that's where it looses credibility in my opinion. This is Piggyback Guides, they generally do that sort of thing anyways. And besides, they made it clear that the only reason they are speculating is because they were basically forbidden to explicitly state who Ishmael's true identity is.